{"id": "b5dc646", "room": "71b90d0", "text": "Guidance was stated more confidently than the evidence supported", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/b5dc646-guidance-stated-confidently-evidence", "json": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/b5dc646.json", "embed": "https://truecauses.org/embed/71b90d0/b5dc646", "room_url": "https://truecauses.org/d/71b90d0", "question": "Why do false claims spread faster than corrections?", "kind": "barriers", "relation": "significantly influences", "source": "walkthrough", "demonstration": true, "room_is": "a walkthrough with stand-ins — a demonstration, not a finding", "stands": false, "stage": 6, "sealed": true, "root": false, "shortlisted": true, "leads_to": [], "comes_from": [], "links": [{"pair": "172c22a>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "172c22a", "text": "So the incentive is to revise quietly rather than loudly", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/172c22a-incentive-revise-quietly-loudly"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 14, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "26c52fc>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "26c52fc", "text": "Anyone with relevant expertise has funding from someone with an interest", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/26c52fc-relevant-expertise-funding"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "33bc9bf>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "33bc9bf", "text": "Reversing guidance is used as proof the whole thing was a lie", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/33bc9bf-reversing-guidance-proof-lie"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "4b23023>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "4b23023", "text": "A minister needs an answer this week and the study reports next year", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/4b23023-minister-answer-week-study-reports"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "72ae2d9>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "72ae2d9", "text": "Retracting a paper takes years and the claim travels in days", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/72ae2d9-retracting-paper-takes-claim-travels"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "7383d70>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "7383d70", "text": "Nobody has ever measured what a late correction costs", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/7383d70-measured-late-correction-costs"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 5, "no": 22, "abstain": 2}}, {"pair": "9486010>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "9486010", "text": "Being wrong in public costs an institution more than being slow", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/9486010-wrong-public-costs-institution-slow"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 5, "no": 22, "abstain": 2}}, {"pair": "a4286de>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "a4286de", "text": "Emergency powers suspend the checks that would have caught it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/a4286de-emergency-powers-suspend-checks-caught"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>172c22a", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "172c22a", "text": "So the incentive is to revise quietly rather than loudly", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/172c22a-incentive-revise-quietly-loudly"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>26c52fc", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "26c52fc", "text": "Anyone with relevant expertise has funding from someone with an interest", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/26c52fc-relevant-expertise-funding"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 10, "abstain": 2}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>33bc9bf", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "33bc9bf", "text": "Reversing guidance is used as proof the whole thing was a lie", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/33bc9bf-reversing-guidance-proof-lie"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>4b23023", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "4b23023", "text": "A minister needs an answer this week and the study reports next year", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/4b23023-minister-answer-week-study-reports"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 14, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>72ae2d9", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "72ae2d9", "text": "Retracting a paper takes years and the claim travels in days", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/72ae2d9-retracting-paper-takes-claim-travels"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>7383d70", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "7383d70", "text": "Nobody has ever measured what a late correction costs", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/7383d70-measured-late-correction-costs"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 5, "no": 21, "abstain": 3}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>9486010", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "9486010", "text": "Being wrong in public costs an institution more than being slow", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/9486010-wrong-public-costs-institution-slow"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 3, "no": 11, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>a4286de", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "a4286de", "text": "Emergency powers suspend the checks that would have caught it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/a4286de-emergency-powers-suspend-checks-caught"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 7, "no": 22, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b5dc646>c1071f1", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "c1071f1", "text": "There is no routine moment at which guidance is re-examined", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/c1071f1-routine-moment-guidance-re-examined"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 7, "no": 21, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "c1071f1>b5dc646", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "c1071f1", "text": "There is no routine moment at which guidance is re-examined", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/71b90d0/c1071f1-routine-moment-guidance-re-examined"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 11, "abstain": 1}}], "atlas": {"id": "naa3668485251f24c", "url": "https://truecauses.org/atlas?q=Guidance%20was%20stated%20more%20confidently%20than%20the%20evidence%20suppo"}, "note": "a group’s judgement, not a measurement. Demo room", "attribution": "Causal map: True Causes, https://truecauses.org/d/71b90d0"}