{"id": "f13f3d3", "room": "c29b4cd", "text": "Guidance was stated more confidently than the evidence supported", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/f13f3d3-guidance-stated-confidently-evidence", "json": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/f13f3d3.json", "embed": "https://truecauses.org/embed/c29b4cd/f13f3d3", "room_url": "https://truecauses.org/d/c29b4cd", "question": "Why are corrections never as loud as the claim?", "kind": "barriers", "relation": "significantly influences", "source": "walkthrough", "demonstration": true, "room_is": "a walkthrough with stand-ins — a demonstration, not a finding", "stands": false, "stage": 6, "sealed": true, "root": false, "shortlisted": true, "leads_to": ["0679477", "f59a837"], "comes_from": ["0679477", "11f4bc2", "7500d79"], "links": [{"pair": "0679477>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "0679477", "text": "The metric is claims processed", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/0679477-metric-claims-processed"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 14, "no": 0, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "11f4bc2>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "11f4bc2", "text": "We label the claim and cannot label the confidence", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/11f4bc2-label-claim-label-confidence"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 13, "no": 0, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "331959f>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "331959f", "text": "We say we are independent and the audience is right to ask how", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/331959f-independent-audience"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "4e639f7>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "4e639f7", "text": "Editors ask whether anyone else has run it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/4e639f7-editors"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 5, "no": 23, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "64ccef7>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "64ccef7", "text": "Nobody is checking the structure that produced the claim", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/64ccef7-checking-structure-produced-claim"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 11, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "7500d79>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "7500d79", "text": "We are asked to check claims, not the guidance that generated them", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/7500d79-check-claims-guidance-generated"}, "verdict": "inferred", "by": "inferred", "votes": {"yes": 7, "no": 6, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "ab65a4d>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "ab65a4d", "text": "A newsroom cannot hold a specialist for every field", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/ab65a4d-newsroom-hold-specialist-field"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "b16931c>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "b16931c", "text": "By the time we could confirm it, it was old", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/b16931c-time-confirm"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>0679477", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "0679477", "text": "The metric is claims processed", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/0679477-metric-claims-processed"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 14, "no": 0, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>11f4bc2", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "11f4bc2", "text": "We label the claim and cannot label the confidence", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/11f4bc2-label-claim-label-confidence"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>331959f", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "331959f", "text": "We say we are independent and the audience is right to ask how", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/331959f-independent-audience"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>4e639f7", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "4e639f7", "text": "Editors ask whether anyone else has run it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/4e639f7-editors"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 11, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>64ccef7", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "64ccef7", "text": "Nobody is checking the structure that produced the claim", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/64ccef7-checking-structure-produced-claim"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>7500d79", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "7500d79", "text": "We are asked to check claims, not the guidance that generated them", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/7500d79-check-claims-guidance-generated"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>ab65a4d", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "ab65a4d", "text": "A newsroom cannot hold a specialist for every field", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/ab65a4d-newsroom-hold-specialist-field"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>b16931c", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "b16931c", "text": "By the time we could confirm it, it was old", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/b16931c-time-confirm"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 13, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "f13f3d3>f59a837", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "f59a837", "text": "Our funding is project-based and follows whatever is topical", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/f59a837-funding-project-based-topical"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 12, "no": 1, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "f59a837>f13f3d3", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "f59a837", "text": "Our funding is project-based and follows whatever is topical", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/c29b4cd/f59a837-funding-project-based-topical"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 3, "no": 11, "abstain": 0}}], "atlas": {"id": "naa3668485251f24c", "url": "https://truecauses.org/atlas?q=Guidance%20was%20stated%20more%20confidently%20than%20the%20evidence%20suppo"}, "note": "a group’s judgement, not a measurement. Demo room", "attribution": "Causal map: True Causes, https://truecauses.org/d/c29b4cd"}