{"id": "00ab7e2", "room": "e74d06f", "text": "Peer review is three unpaid people on a deadline", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/00ab7e2-peer-review-unpaid-people-deadline", "json": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/00ab7e2.json", "embed": "https://truecauses.org/embed/e74d06f/00ab7e2", "room_url": "https://truecauses.org/d/e74d06f", "question": "Why does a lie travel further than the truth?", "kind": "barriers", "relation": "significantly influences", "source": "walkthrough", "demonstration": true, "room_is": "a walkthrough with stand-ins — a demonstration, not a finding", "stands": false, "stage": 6, "sealed": true, "root": true, "shortlisted": true, "leads_to": ["1e578b8", "a73a657", "e145ba7"], "comes_from": [], "links": [{"pair": "00ab7e2>067b199", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "067b199", "text": "There is no body whose job is to be wrong-footed early", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/067b199-body-job-wrong-footed"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 11, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>1e578b8", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "1e578b8", "text": "A researcher who audits a funder's work loses the funder", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/1e578b8-researcher-audits-funder-loses-funder"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 13, "no": 1, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>59affa7", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "59affa7", "text": "So institutions treat all criticism as one category and answer none of it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/59affa7-institutions-treat-criticism-category"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 3, "no": 10, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>74dc188", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "74dc188", "text": "Institutions investigate themselves and find nothing", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/74dc188-institutions-investigate"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 13, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>a58cf12", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "a58cf12", "text": "Being unable to reproduce a result is not itself publishable", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/a58cf12-unable-reproduce-result-publishable"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 13, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>a73a657", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "a73a657", "text": "The reply is that release would be misinterpreted by the public", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/a73a657-reply-release-misinterpreted-public"}, "verdict": "yes", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 14, "no": 0, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>d53506d", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "d53506d", "text": "Each revision is announced as if it were the position all along", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/d53506d-revision-announced-position"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 14, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>e145ba7", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "e145ba7", "text": "A genuine critic and a bad-faith one look identical from a distance", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/e145ba7-genuine-critic-bad-faith-identical"}, "verdict": "inferred", "by": "inferred", "votes": {"yes": 5, "no": 9, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "00ab7e2>e9fc936", "role": "cause", "other": {"id": "e9fc936", "text": "You cannot check a claim whose data is not released", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/e9fc936-check-claim-data-released"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 12, "abstain": 2}}, {"pair": "067b199>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "067b199", "text": "There is no body whose job is to be wrong-footed early", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/067b199-body-job-wrong-footed"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 3, "no": 10, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "1e578b8>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "1e578b8", "text": "A researcher who audits a funder's work loses the funder", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/1e578b8-researcher-audits-funder-loses-funder"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "cross-group", "votes": {"yes": 6, "no": 22, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "59affa7>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "59affa7", "text": "So institutions treat all criticism as one category and answer none of it", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/59affa7-institutions-treat-criticism-category"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 13, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "74dc188>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "74dc188", "text": "Institutions investigate themselves and find nothing", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/74dc188-institutions-investigate"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 11, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "a58cf12>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "a58cf12", "text": "Being unable to reproduce a result is not itself publishable", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/a58cf12-unable-reproduce-result-publishable"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 2, "no": 12, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "a73a657>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "a73a657", "text": "The reply is that release would be misinterpreted by the public", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/a73a657-reply-release-misinterpreted-public"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 14, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "d53506d>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "d53506d", "text": "Each revision is announced as if it were the position all along", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/d53506d-revision-announced-position"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 3, "no": 11, "abstain": 0}}, {"pair": "e145ba7>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "e145ba7", "text": "A genuine critic and a bad-faith one look identical from a distance", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/e145ba7-genuine-critic-bad-faith-identical"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 0, "no": 13, "abstain": 1}}, {"pair": "e9fc936>00ab7e2", "role": "effect", "other": {"id": "e9fc936", "text": "You cannot check a claim whose data is not released", "url": "https://truecauses.org/c/e74d06f/e9fc936-check-claim-data-released"}, "verdict": "no", "by": "panel", "votes": {"yes": 1, "no": 12, "abstain": 1}}], "atlas": {"id": "n53a6eae5999e687f", "url": "https://truecauses.org/atlas?q=Peer%20review%20is%20three%20unpaid%20people%20on%20a%20deadline"}, "note": "a group’s judgement, not a measurement. Demo room", "attribution": "Causal map: True Causes, https://truecauses.org/d/e74d06f"}