True Causes
PCM
SYLLOGISM CHECKER

E follow say “Some politician na rich pesin”?

From two starting points: “Some politician na honest pesin” and “Some honest pesin na rich pesin”.

Write am as three sentences
No be by force. Di parts wey dey below go fill demself from wetin you write; or skip dis one and name di parts directly.
Di built-in reader read am at once. Make Claude read am too — e dey rebuild everyday wording wey di built-in reader dey take word for word; dem still dey calculate di verdict here.
Try one:

Di claimdi tin wey you dey tok about, and wetin you tok say e true about am

→

Di bridgedi property wey di two starting points share, and di conclusion no dey ever mention

Di two linkstok each one as strong as you fit defend am, no pass dat — ⇄ dey turn im direction

Di oda half: how to check whether di starting points true
Dis page dey answer one question — di conclusion follow by logic? E no dey tok anytin about whether di starting points true, and di trick wey pipo dey use pass for argument na perfect logic on top premise wey nobodi check. Machine no fit do dat half, so dis na di checklist. Ask am of evri side di same way, your own side inside.
1 · Find di premise wey carry di load
Wetin di whole argument really hang on?
  • Which claim, if e fall, go carry di conclusion fall with am?
  • Wetin dem present as clear, but for true pipo dey argue am?
  • Wetin I go don already believe make dis one make sense?
  • Which step from di reasons to di conclusion nobodi tok?
2 · If na fact wey pesin fit check
Numbers, documents, events — open dem.
  • Which source confirm am, and I fit open dat source myself?
  • Di source tok exactly dat one, or sometin wey dem change for road?
  • Wetin go prove say dis claim no true?
  • If source no dey, why source no dey?
3 · If na value judgement
Nobodi go settle value for you; dis questions just dey show wetin dey hide.
  • Na whose value, and evribodi wey dey here accept am as given?
  • I go use di same judgement for di oda side?
  • Na fact dem dress up as value, or value dem dress up as fact?
  • Wetin pesin wey no gree — and wey no be bad pesin — go tok?
4 · If na prediction, or claim about wetin pesin intend
Nobodi fit check any of dem now. Shine your eye wen dem tok any of dem as fact.
  • How anybodi go take know wetin anoda pesin intend — wia di evidence dey, instead of di feeling?
  • Dem dey treat sometin wey nobodi fit prove like say e don already settle?
  • Wetin go confirm or reject dis prediction, and by wen?
  • Na fear dey stand for di place of evidence?
5 · Two questions for evri argument, no exception
  • Wetin go convince you say you wrong? If notin fit, dis na faith, no be argument.
  • I fit put di same question to di side wey I gree with?
For dialogue, na for dis di panel dey: na di pipo wey sabi di situation dey decide whether starting point true, no be dis page and no be model.
Claude dey read your sentences into structure; na fixed engine dey calculate di verdict here, neva di model.
dialogues · Arguments from public debate