COMPARED
Kialo is a well-known argument-mapping and debate site, with a free version for classrooms, Kialo Edu. A discussion starts from one thesis; people add pro and con claims under it, and each claim can have its own pros and cons, forming a tree. It is widely used to teach critical thinking.
True Causes is built for root cause analysis: many problems, and which of them influence which. One of its other kinds of map, Claims and reasons, maps an argument with the same method. Everyone writes claims on their own; the group judges, a pair at a time, whether one claim gives a reason to accept another; a link is kept at three quarters of the votes. The result is a network rather than a tree: one claim can support several others, and the premises the argument rests on come out at the root.
| Kialo | True Causes | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | What are the arguments for and against this thesis? | Which claims are reasons for which, and what does the argument rest on? Or, in its main use, what causes what? |
| What people do | Add pro and con claims under a thesis, and under each other's claims | Everyone writes claims alone; the group then judges one pair at a time: does this claim give a reason to accept that one? |
| What comes out | A tree of arguments under one thesis | A map of reasons with the premises at the root, or a map of causes with the deepest first, and every disagreement kept on it |
| Objections | A con claim, filed under the claim it opposes | A claim of its own, judged like any other |
| How a point counts | Claims are rated by participants | A link counts at three quarters of the votes cast; a split is published as disputed |
| Scale | One shared discussion that grows as people add to it | Many small rooms on one question, each judging on its own, their maps folded into one |
| Best known for | Debate and critical-thinking teaching | Root cause analysis by the whole group |
| Cost | Free, including for educators | Free up to 100 people per room; nonprofits free on approval; paid plans for organisations |
| Names | Anonymous contributions available in Kialo Edu | Nobody is named inside a room |
| Private discussions | Private debates for invited students | Private, unlisted or public rooms; results can be held until a date |
| Discussion | A chat box per debate | A short side discussion beside each card and each pair |
| Sources | Claims can link sources | Overlooked cards backed by a source can take reserved places on the shortlist |
| Analytics | Class-level voting statistics | The vote counts of every judged pair, downloadable |
When you want the reasons for and against one thesis laid out side by side: a class debate, a public discussion that grows over weeks, teaching people to separate claims from evidence.
When the group has to decide which claims actually hold, not only list them: each link is voted, and a split stays on the map as a split. Choose Claims and reasons for an argument about one proposition, and the default kind of map, Obstacles, when there is no single thesis, only a situation with many problems and the question of which drive the others. Because rooms on one question fold into one map, the same argument can be worked through by many small groups at once. True Causes also has a small logic checker for the moment a dispute turns on whether one reason really follows from another.
Checked in September 2026. Product names belong to their owners. If anything here about another product is out of date or unfair, write to hello@mg.truecauses.org and we will correct it.
All comparisons · Formats, drawn · Why True Causes · Try it in five minutes