LA QUESTION
Why does environmental regulation get weakened?
L’une influence-t-elle fortement l’autre ? Les trois quarts des votes exprimés décident.
fermé · retour à la phase Actions
Mode invité. Choisissez un pseudo pour rejoindre la salle et participer.
Les questions sont réparties entre les groupes : vous recevez celles attribuées à votre groupe — pas toutes les 90.
tranchées : 6 / 90 à vous de répondre : 0 contestées : 2 (mises de côté, visibles) pourquoi
Personne ne pourrait répondre à plusieurs centaines de paires. Chaque paire va à un groupe ; une paire sur laquelle le groupe se divise est ensuite renvoyée à d’autres groupes, et peut donc apparaître plus tard dans votre liste même si elle a commencé ailleurs. Le nombre de paires tranchées inclut le travail de tous les groupes : c’est pourquoi il monte plus vite que votre propre liste ne diminue.
Dernier décompte : tranchées : 4 · transmises à des panels inter-groupes : 0 · contestées : 2 · sous le quorum : 84 — les panels ont besoin d’au moins max(2, 75 % du panel) votes exprimés ; votre plus petit panel compte 12 membres.
Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. → influence ? → Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster.
I’ve watched small businesses like mine get left behind when rules are drafted assuming corporate resources. The ones that can’t afford compliance staff end up having to cut corners or go out of business, which makes it easier for the team to justify ‘clearing permits faster’ by ignoring what’s left of the rule.
modérateur I've never seen a rule gutted due to small shops' inability to follow them. Our agency doesn't target small shops for enforcement.
I have seen senior engineers actively negotiating for exemptions that dilute environmental safeguards, framing these reductions as necessary trade-offs for speed rather than compliance failures.
I have witnessed many minor modification permits being rubber‑stamped without close review due to time constraints.
I have observed senior engineers negotiating exemptions to speed up permits, but I have not seen a direct link to the rule‑writing process for large firms.
In my cost-of-compliance work I see the small-firm burden directly — fixed compliance costs hit a 5-person shop far harder than a 5,000-person firm — but that burden explains why small firms ignore rules; it does not explain why senior engineers negotiate exemptions for permit speed. Different actors, different mechanism.
I have seen the same rule read completely differently from the agency side and the industry side, and I know how easily a rule gets gutted when the people writing it assume lawyers and compliance staff.
I have no visibility into whether small business struggles drive the specific permit negotiation tactics used by senior engineers.
I've seen rules that assume a compliance department we don't have, so we skip what we can't afford.
Phase terminée — l’archive des paires et des votes figure ci-dessus.Vérifier la logique ↗
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ⚑ contesté | discussion (9) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ⚑ contesté | discussion (9) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (16) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (14) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (15) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | au premier plan ↑ · fermer ✕ |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (14) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (7) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (15) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (18) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (16) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (8) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | ouvert | discussion (7) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (7) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ouvert | discussion (9) |
| Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ouvert | discussion (12) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | ouvert | discussion (6) |
| Rules weaken because officials who leave the agency for industry can return, so they water down rules. | → | Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | → | The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| The studies driving repeal are funded by industry, so the evidence base itself skews toward cutting rules. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (6) |
| Weakened environmental regulation often occurs due to powerful economic interests lobbying against stricter laws. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ouvert | discussion (11) |
| Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | → | Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | ouvert | discussion (13) |
| Rules get weakened because full enforcement would bankrupt small shops, and politicians know it. | → | Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | ouvert | discussion (14) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Rules get written for big corporations, and small shops like mine can't afford to follow them, so they get gutted. | ouvert | discussion (10) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Flares happen at night when I'm sleeping, but I still pay the medical bills when my son has asthma attacks from the haze. | ✓ oui | discussion (9) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ✗ non | discussion (9) |
| Our teams weaken regulations to clear permits faster. | → | Because lawmakers cut the enforcement budget to save money, making inspectors like me scarce and enforcement weaker. | ✗ non | discussion (9) |
| Rulemaking notice periods happen while I'm sanding fenders, so I never get to comment. | → | Industry tests drafts with ex-regulators, so the final rules already have known workarounds. | ✗ non | discussion (11) |