PYTANIE
Why does environmental regulation get weakened?
Czy jedno istotnie wpływa na drugie? Decydują trzy czwarte oddanych głosów.
zamknięte · wróć do etapu Działania
Podgląd jako gość. Podaj nazwę użytkownika, żeby dołączyć i wziąć udział.
Pytania są rozdzielane między grupy, więc dostajesz te, które przypadły Twojej grupie — nie wszystkie (łącznie: 90).
rozstrzygnięte: 10 / 90 do odpowiedzi: 0 sporne: 8 (odłożone, widoczne) dlaczego
Nikt nie odpowie na kilkaset par. Każda para trafia do jednej grupy; para, przy której zdania się podzieliły, jest potem kierowana do innych grup, więc może pojawić się później na Twojej liście, choć zaczęła gdzie indziej. Liczba rozstrzygniętych obejmuje pracę wszystkich grup, dlatego rośnie szybciej, niż maleje Twoja lista.
Ostatnie liczenie głosów: rozstrzygnięte: 2 · przekazane panelom międzygrupowym: 0 · sporne: 8 · poniżej kworum: 80 — panele potrzebują co najmniej max(2, 75% panelu) oddanych głosów; Twój najmniejszy panel ma 12 członków.
Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. → wpływa? → I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill.
I've never seen the drafting process or the lobbying efforts firsthand, so I can't say if businesses reducing support for rules influences someone drafting language to weaken enforcement. I only know what happens in my lab and around my workplace.
I have seen that lobbying targets specific bill language to ensure fines remain unenforceable.
The author knows that businesses sometimes pressure lawmakers to weaken environmental rules, but they have no insight into how drafting language to make fines unenforceable influences those lobbying efforts.
The author of B is deliberately weakening enforcement language, and the author of A describes a mechanism by which that weakening is facilitated.
I've never read the actual permit or any bill language, so I can't judge what a drafter does with the words.
a
The author of A is a business representative, and the author of B is a legislator. The legislator's experience and perspective are likely to be influenced by the business representative's claim, but the legislator's claim is more about their own motivations and actions than about the impact of business lobbying.
I have seen bills with deliberately vague language pass.
a
moderacja I draft the rollback language myself and I know exactly which adjectives make a fine unenforceable, and I choose them because closing the plant closes my seat — not because I can see lobbying shifting support among my colleagues.
Etap zakończony — zapis par i głosów jest powyżej.Sprawdź logikę ↗
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (9) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (8) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (11) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (10) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (9) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | ⚑ sporne | dyskusja (8) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (18) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (15) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (11) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (12) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (13) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (11) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (12) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (4) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (11) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (6) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (14) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (6) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | otwarte | dyskusja (14) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | w centrum uwagi ↑ · zamknij ✕ |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (6) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (13) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (12) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (13) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (11) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | otwarte | dyskusja (6) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | otwarte | dyskusja (10) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | otwarte | dyskusja (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | otwarte | dyskusja (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ✓ tak | dyskusja (16) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ✓ tak | dyskusja (12) |