ПИТАННЯ
Why does environmental regulation get weakened?
Чи суттєво одне впливає на інше? Вирішують три чверті поданих голосів.
закрито · назад до етапу Дії
Ви переглядаєте як гість. Введіть ім’я користувача, щоб приєднатися й брати участь.
Питання розподіляються між групами, тож ви отримуєте ті, що дісталися вашій групі, — а не всі 90.
вирішено: 10 / 90 чекають вашої відповіді: 0 спірних: 8 (відкладено, видно) чому
Ніхто не зміг би відповісти на кілька сотень пар. Кожна пара дістається одній групі; пару, у якій думки розділилися, потім передають іншим групам, тож вона може пізніше з’явитися у вашому списку, хоча почалася деінде. Кількість вирішених охоплює роботу всіх груп, тому вона росте швидше, ніж скорочується ваш список.
Останній підрахунок: вирішено: 2 · передано міжгруповим панелям: 0 · спірно: 8 · нижче кворуму: 80 — панелям потрібно щонайменше max(2, 75% панелі) поданих голосів; у вашій найменшій панелі 12 учасників.
Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. → впливає на? → Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written.
I see internal memos where we track lobbying spend to shape bills before drafting begins.
The author does not mention any evidence that business lobbying influences lawmakers, so the first claim cannot be judged.
If donors get their asks written in before a word is on paper, that's the lobbying doing its work — the weakening of support happens right there.
The author has firsthand experience of lobbying by businesses reducing support for rules, but they cannot say whether this influence significantly impacts the perception of industry pressure reaching lawmakers before bills are written.
I have heard donors influence bills.
Lobbying by businesses (A) is a specific mechanism through which industry pressure reaches lawmakers (B). A directly supports and exemplifies the claim that industry pressure shapes legislation before it is written.
модератор I've watched three donors lay out what the bill should say before I've written a word, and that is exactly the pressure that weakens support for the rules — I see the mechanism working both directions at once.
Етап завершено — запис пар і голосів наведено вище.Перевірити логіку ↗
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (9) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (8) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (11) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (10) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (9) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | ⚑ спірно | обговорення (8) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (18) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (15) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (11) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (12) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (13) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (11) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (12) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (4) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (11) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | у фокусі ↑ · закрити ✕ |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (6) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (14) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (6) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | відкрито | обговорення (14) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (6) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (13) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (12) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (13) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (11) |
| Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | Industry pressure reaches lawmakers before bills are written. | відкрито | обговорення (6) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | → | I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Nobody ever posts the permit or test results where folks downstream can read them. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | відкрито | обговорення (10) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (9) |
| I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | → | Environmental regulation gets weakened because it's repackaged as modernization or flexibility, dressed up as reform. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| As experienced regulators retire, critical institutional knowledge is lost, making it easier for industry to dismantle hard-won protections from within. | → | Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | The creek changes color some mornings and nobody ever tells us what happened that day. | відкрито | обговорення (7) |
| I see the plant's name on the library and the fire trucks, and that makes enforcement feel like punishment. | → | I draft the language myself and know which words kill enforcement before anyone reads the bill. | відкрито | обговорення (8) |
| Lobbying by businesses reduces support for rules. | → | Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | ✓ так | обговорення (16) |
| Downstream communities suffer health impacts from untreated effluent, but their concerns go unheard in rule-making. | → | Nobody ever asks the people living downstream, so the folks who make the rules only hear from the plant. | ✓ так | обговорення (12) |