THE QUESTION
Why do people prefer their own information bubble?
Group cards you judge alike. Groups organise reading; they decide nothing.
closed · back to Actions
Viewing as guest. Enter a handle to join and take part.
Clusters form from similarity, names come last
Canonical order: link pairs of ideas you judge similar — links are symmetric (A~B is B~A; direction never matters) and a tie holds once 2 members make it.
why
Links are symmetric — A~B is B~A. Clusters are the groups that emerge from held ties, and only a formed cluster can be named, by a person. Your own links carry a ✕ to withdraw; you cannot remove someone else's. Clusters organise the wall and never gate the vote — two cards making the same CLAIM are a merge back in Clarify.
Links and names are made while Cluster is live; the steward’s ← reopens it.
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Schools do not teach how to read a source
~ Media literacy is tau…Media literacy is taught once, by whoever has a free period (18)
Media literacy is taught once, by whoever has a free period
~ Schools do not teach …Schools do not teach how to read a source (18)
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Local newspapers closed and nothing replaced them
~ The last local report…The last local reporter covers four towns and a court (16)
The last local reporter covers four towns and a court
~ Local newspapers clos…Local newspapers closed and nothing replaced them (16)
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
The people most online are the least representative
~ People are exhausted …People are exhausted and take the version that costs least to hold (18)
People are exhausted and take the version that costs least to hold
~ The people most onlin…The people most online are the least representative (18)
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
A rumour in a village group reaches more people than the council's own notice
~ People do not want mo…People do not want more information, they want to stop being anxious (12)
People do not want more information, they want to stop being anxious
~ A rumour in a village…A rumour in a village group reaches more people than the council's own notice (12)
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Distrust of one institution spreads to all of them
~ Everyone can name a t…Everyone can name a time they were lied to by someone official (21)
Everyone can name a time they were lied to by someone official
~ Everything local now …Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone (18)
~ Distrust of one insti…Distrust of one institution spreads to all of them (21)
· not yet clustered (33)
Nobody knows who runs the biggest local page
~ Everything local now …Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone (18)
Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone
~ Nobody knows who runs…Nobody knows who runs the biggest local page (18)
~ Nobody teaches how to…Nobody teaches how to be wrong in public without losing face (15)
~ The word 'bubble' ass…The word 'bubble' assumes there is an outside, and nobody can point at it (18)
~ Nobody outside the co…Nobody outside the company can check whether moderation is even applied (11)
~ Everyone can name a t…Everyone can name a time they were lied to by someone official (18)
Ad money rewards volume of attention, not quality of it
We are describing the collapse of local life and calling it a technology problem
The bubble is not online; it is who your children go to school with
Removing a post makes it famous
We built a public square with no seats and no closing time
Every attempt to fix this has been run by the people it is about
~ Nobody has ever been …Nobody has ever been persuaded by a fact-check they did not ask for (14)
~ The regional paper is…The regional paper is written by people who have never been here (15)
~ The council meeting h…The council meeting has not been reported by anyone for six years (14)
Appeals go to the same system that made the decision
Nobody has ever been persuaded by a fact-check they did not ask for
~ Every attempt to fix …Every attempt to fix this has been run by the people it is about (14)
~ The council meeting h…The council meeting has not been reported by anyone for six years (18)
~ Anonymity was the onl…Anonymity was the only thing that ever made people ask real questions (15)
~ Nobody has time to be…Nobody has time to be a citizen after two jobs (13)
The curriculum has no room for anything that is not examined
People choose the sources that already agree with them
Libraries lost the hours when people used to come and read
Nobody teaches how to be wrong in public without losing face
~ Everything local now …Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone (15)
The one place everyone still meets is the school gate
Children learn what a source is from their parents' feed
Nobody outside the company can check whether moderation is even applied
~ Everything local now …Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone (11)
~ The word 'bubble' ass…The word 'bubble' assumes there is an outside, and nobody can point at it (12)
The word 'bubble' assumes there is an outside, and nobody can point at it
~ Everything local now …Everything local now happens in a group nobody can join without knowing someone (18)
~ Nobody outside the co…Nobody outside the company can check whether moderation is even applied (12)
Politics is the only thing left that is free to talk about
~ Anonymity was the onl…Anonymity was the only thing that ever made people ask real questions (13)
The rules are written for one country and applied to forty
Teachers are afraid to bring politics into a classroom at all
Ranking optimises for time spent, not for being informed
There is no shared set of facts to argue from any more
Anonymity was the only thing that ever made people ask real questions
~ Politics is the only …Politics is the only thing left that is free to talk about (13)
~ Nobody has ever been …Nobody has ever been persuaded by a fact-check they did not ask for (15)
The problem is not the algorithm, it is that everyone is watching
A teenager can spot a fake photo and not a fake framing
A report takes three days and the post has already done its work
Nobody has time to be a citizen after two jobs
~ Nobody has ever been …Nobody has ever been persuaded by a fact-check they did not ask for (13)
Two generations have never seen an adult change their mind about anything
~ The regional paper is…The regional paper is written by people who have never been here (15)
The regional paper is written by people who have never been here
~ Two generations have …Two generations have never seen an adult change their mind about anything (15)
~ Every attempt to fix …Every attempt to fix this has been run by the people it is about (15)
There is no way to say 'I have changed my mind' without it counting against you
The young left and the argument stayed
The council meeting has not been reported by anyone for six years