在线公民审议:从众多声音到一张市政部门可以据此行动的原因地图 征求意见收集看法,投票统计看法。两者都说不出问题为什么反复出现,而且通常是最显眼的投诉胜出。在美国政府 2009 年的“开放政府对话”(Open Government Dialogue)中,得票最多的想法包括大麻合法化和总统的出生证明,旁边还有要求公开 UFO 档案的呼声;各机构最后搁置了想法投票:整理收到的内容所花的代价,超过了它带来的收获(Farina et al., 2014)。市政部门最后拿到一份排了序的投诉清单,其中大多数是某个没人排过序的东西造成的后果。
True Causes 是一个结构化审议平台。居民各自独立、不署名地写下原因,阅读并澄清彼此的原因,然后在小房间里逐对判断一个原因是否显著影响另一个原因,每一对都先讨论,再表决。只有四分之三的人同意,一条关联才会上地图;意见分裂就作为分裂公布。它以结构化民主对话为基础,这种方法五十年来一直用于公民对话。
它像城市一样生长。每个街区、学校或选区都可以就同一个已发布的问题开自己的房间;房间可以向某个邮件域名开放,这样市政部门的员工或大学的学生无需其他任何东西就能加入;每个房间的地图会合并成一张,显示哪些原因是许多房间各自独立找到的。每条关联、每个票数和每个房间都留在记录中,任何人都可以阅读、核查和引用结果。
与 Pol.is 对比 · 与 Decidim 对比 · 审议平台功能逐项对比 · 如何运作
Why does a steady life take more than it used to?
一张完成的地图,来自由模拟成员运行的演示。
Nobody in a ministry has ever met a payroll The things that used to be bought once are now rented… The rules make dismissal costly, so we do not hire… A large competitor can absorb a regulation that… Employers' taxes are charged on the person, so… Every new rule consolidates the market a little more Business representation is dominated by firms unlike… Hiring someone permanently now feels like signing a… A machine is a capital allowance and a worker is … So we use contracts and agencies and everyone loses Assets rose faster than wages for four decades ⟳ Every cost that rose was passed to us and could not… ⟳ Energy, rent and insurance tripled and the invoice di… ⟳ So nobody trains and everyone complains about… Consolidation removes the employer competition that… We would pay more if the work carried the price What used to be a job is now a series of contracts A single wage no longer supports a household Cash flow, not profit, decides whether anyone is… 打开它,点击任意一条主张 →