True Causes
EN
PASSPORT · WHAT THIS ROOM DID

Why do atrocities go unpunished?

Every line is from the record. Nothing is computed for this page, and nothing is smoothed: a short list of disagreements means a room that agreed, not a room whose disagreements were tidied away.

structuresobstacles
opened8 September 2026
who answered30 people in 2 groups · participant: 30
wrote blindnot recorded
claims37 written, 20 structured
links certified10
rooms on this question7 · counts toward the shared map
decided at75% of the votes cast
sealedyes, members forgotten
What it rests on
  • Every state judges the case by what it costs them
  • So the organisation that knows most says least
  • Naming it triggers obligations, so it is not named
  • Early warning systems produce reports nobody is obliged to answer
  • Acting early is politically costly and acting late is not punished
  • Speaking publicly ends the access that lets us feed people
What it could not settle
Published as contested, never recorded as a no.
  • none: every pair the room reached was settled
What was predicted to follow
Written after the map settled. Nobody voted on it.
  • Protect the mandate of an organisation that speaks — expected: more warnings get a written answer once answering is somebody's duty — due 24 March 2027
What the room would do
Each action judged against each root cause, at three quarters of the votes cast.
The numbers
Counted from the record: the pair list, the votes behind it, the map, and the stage clock. Anyone who holds the record can recount them.
pairs asked
180
links certified
10
judged not linked
160
contested
0
escalated
9
still open
1
votes cast
2739
abstentions
141
links by provenance: paneled 10
how long each stage stayed open: Clarify 0 s · Cluster 1 s · Select 0 s · Structure 1 s · Map 0 s · question to map: 23.0 h
Cite this dialogue
_2bf9162589 (2026). Why do atrocities go unpunished? [structured dialogue, root cause map]. True Causes. https://truecauses.org/d/59eaba9. Retrieved 16 November 2026.
@misc{truecauses59eaba9,
  author = {_2bf9162589},
  title = {Why do atrocities go unpunished?},
  year = {2026},
  howpublished = {True Causes, structured dialogue 59eaba9},
  url = {https://truecauses.org/d/59eaba9},
  note = {30 participants in 2 groups; 10 certified links; accessed 2026-11-16}
}
Machine-readable: every judged pair (CSV) · this passport (JSON)

← the dialogue