READ FROM PUBLIC DISCUSSION
The pool
Claims a model read out of public threads, each with a link to the comment it came from. Nobody judged any of it: a room certifies a link when three quarters of a group say so, and nothing here has been through that. A claim came from one comment; a link came from one comment; no path through this was asserted by anybody. What is counted is how many communities and how many distinct people — never a total, which would read as a score it has not earned. Open questions.
395 claims · 5 asserted links · 48 the atlas already holds5 thin
ASSERTED LINKS
Building more housing in desirable areas attracts more people. → Upzoning would not make a place like Manhattan more affordable.
thin · refused in news.ycombinator.com
Local control laws allow anyone to stop development in others' yards. → Zoning irresponsibly near heavy transit restricts housing development.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Laws and regulation prevent housing supply from increasing → Most voters are homeowners with a vested interest in increasing home value
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Increasing the supply of housing will lower the price in the long term → Increasing the supply of housing will raise the price in the short term
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Tokyo solves affordability with economies of scale around prefabricated buildings. → The US needs to relax zoning rules for economies of scale.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
CLAIMS
Building costs are very high in San Francisco.
Seattle has added roughly 100,000 jobs but only 32,000 new homes.
Private equity firms are buying homes and maximizing profits.
The US needs to build more homes to address affordability.
Personal automobiles create issues when required for daily tasks.
Housing costs cause people with issues to become homeless.
Restricting prices won't create more living space for people.
Building more homes can make an area more unaffordable according to the formula.
California's housing policy has led to exorbitant housing costs for many people.
Changing zoning laws will help solve housing unaffordability.
Development in the Cambridge area is hampered by inadequate transport.
Single-family homes are more expensive than multi-family housing.
Laws and regulation prevent housing supply from increasing
Zoning and insane levels of regulation cause housing crises in the US.
Americans resist urban planning that limits large homes like McMansions
Ubiquitous up-zoning of every parcel would dramatically increase housing supply.
Building homes in reservoirs leads to housing problems.
Planning permission creates artificial limits on housing supply.
Zoning regulations make development difficult and limit market competition.
Refusing to allow apartments means only the rich can live there.
Building in remote areas reduces the importance of land cost.
Opposition to density is driven by greed and property value concerns.
Attractive neighborhoods increase demand, raising living costs.
Building denser housing reduces costs per unit for residents.
Distributing economic viability more widely would help housing affordability.
Zoning bottlenecks housing changes, leading to abrupt transitions in types.
Existing property owners oppose policies that decrease their property value.
Rapid population growth in west coast cities is not sustainable for much longer.
Upzoning alone won't dramatically decrease rents in market economies.
Homeowners have a vested interest in prices going up.
The private sector has never built enough houses.
Tech companies need to be in the Bay Area for talent.
People can't afford housing where the jobs are because there isn't enough housing available.
Dense areas become popular, limiting cheap post-industrial space.
The planning process limits construction companies' ability to build.
Zoning laws and permit requirements are major reasons for unaffordable housing.
Environmental regulations justify low-density development and NIMBY-ism.
People moving to the west coast are causing housing problems.
Investors are not building more houses despite high demand.
Corporations buying single-family homes and townhomes drive up prices.
People move to suburbs to save on housing costs.
House prices have risen while incomes have stagnated
Adding more people increases the costs of providing services.
Silicon Valley is sub-urban, and that causes housing problems.
Exorbitant rent seeking sucks up all marginal resources.
Buying a house far away can lead to high fuel costs.
Most voters are homeowners with a vested interest in increasing home value
Choosing a house further out would increase costs and commute time.
Building luxury apartments causes the cost of surrounding housing to drop.
Zoning prevents more building in my neighborhood.
Developers have an incentive to keep rents overall high.
Foreign investors are buying property
Corporations are buying single-family homes and townhomes
Changing zoning laws will help solve housing affordability issues.
Land is scarce, housing has lots of fixed costs.
Federal mortgage subsidies keep housing prices high.
City officials are homeowners, so they support NIMBY measures.
Bay Area cities prioritize their own interests over neighboring residents.
Willie Brown rezoned everything to accommodate wealthy newcomers.
Removing historic building requirements would facilitate new construction.