DIE FRAGE
Why does a lie travel further than the truth?
Vergeben Sie Ihre Klebepunkte an das, was am wichtigsten ist. Eine Idee mit Beleg kann einen reservierten Platz bekommen.
geschlossen · zurück zu Maßnahmen
Ansicht als Gast. Benutzernamen eingeben, um beizutreten und mitzumachen.
Ihr Klebepunkt-Budget
Einer pro Idee, insgesamt 5. Mindestens eine Stimme.
Reservierte Plätze für übersehene Ideen: 5 — nominieren Sie eine mit Link; sie zählt, sobald 2 Personen zustimmen, dass die Quelle relevant ist.
warum
Am Ende der Phase kommt eine nominierte Idee per Los hinein und die übrigen nach Zahl der Nominierungen, höchstens eine pro Interessengruppe. Ein Modell prüft nur, ob die Seite dasselbe Thema behandelt — nie, ob sie die Behauptung beweist. Dieses Urteil liegt beim Raum, und eine Nominierung, hinter der sonst niemand steht, bekommt keinen Platz.
BÜNDEL 1
Each revision is announced as if it were the position all along
To be precise: this is about the mechanism, not anyone's motives.
Stimmen: 6diskutieren
Requests for data are answered eighteen months later, if at all
Stimmen: 1diskutieren
BÜNDEL 2
Being wrong in public costs an institution more than being slow
Narrower than it reads — the wider claim is someone else's card.
Stimmen: 12diskutieren
Guidance was stated more confidently than the evidence supported
Stimmen: 13diskutieren
BÜNDEL 3
Institutions investigate themselves and find nothing
Stimmen: 13diskutieren
The inquiry reports after everyone involved has retired
Narrower than it reads — the wider claim is someone else's card.
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
BÜNDEL 4
Nobody keeps a public record of which official claims were later revised
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 6diskutieren
The label 'misinformation' is applied to claims that later proved right
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
BÜNDEL 5
You cannot check a claim whose data is not released
Stimmen: 6diskutieren
Once labelled, a claim cannot get a hearing even when the evidence changes
Meaning the general pattern, not one case.
Stimmen: 15diskutieren
BÜNDEL 6
Most of the people qualified to check are inside the system being checked
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
People who were punished for being early are never acknowledged
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
NICHT GEBÜNDELT
Trust falls further from the concealment than it ever would from the error
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
Peer review is three unpaid people on a deadline
Stimmen: 3diskutieren
Fraud is found by volunteers on the internet, years later
Stimmen: 1diskutieren
Being unable to reproduce a result is not itself publishable
Stimmen: 2diskutieren
The cost of dissent is paid by individuals and the benefit is public
I mean this as an observation; I would want it tested.
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
So institutions treat all criticism as one category and answer none of it
Stimmen: 6diskutieren
Replication is unfunded and therefore rare
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 1diskutieren
The bodies that issue guidance also fund those who check it
Stimmen: 7in Diskussion (1)
Platforms enforce the label long after the institution has quietly moved
I mean this as an observation; I would want it tested.
Stimmen: 1diskutieren
There is no body whose job is to be wrong-footed early
Stimmen: 10diskutieren
A correction arrives long after the decision it should have changed
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 13diskutieren
A career is ended by being right too soon
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
The reply is that release would be misinterpreted by the public
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 3diskutieren
A paper that contradicts the field is reviewed harder than one that confirms it
Scope: the last two decades, not all history.
Stimmen: 6diskutieren
The few outside are dismissed as cranks by association
Stimmen: 2diskutieren
The archive of the old guidance disappears from the website
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
A researcher who audits a funder's work loses the funder
Stimmen: 10im Fokus ↑ · schließen ✕
Journalists do not have the specialism to notice a quiet change
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
There is no mechanism to un-label a claim that turned out to be true
To be precise: this is about the mechanism, not anyone's motives.
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
Nobody is compensated for having been correct
I mean this as an observation; I would want it tested.
Stimmen: 0
↳ für einen Platz nominiert: https://example.org/ops-incident-review.pdf could not read it (HTTPError) 1 von 2 dahinter
diskutierenReviewers are chosen from the same small group
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
The correction is technically public and effectively invisible
Stimmen: 0diskutieren
A genuine critic and a bad-faith one look identical from a distance
Stimmen: 6diskutieren