UMBUZO
Why do atrocities go unpunished?
Phakamisani okumele kwenziwe, bese nahlulela ukuthi isenzo ngasinye singayithinta yini impande ngayinye.
Kufakwe uphawu ezinsukwini ezingu-35 ezedlule: leli gumbi alisazi ukuthi obani ababehlezi kulo; ngumphathi walo kuphela osashiwo ngegama. Lokho elakufinyelela kuyahlala.
abangu-30 etafuleni (29 abalingisiwe) · izenzo ezingu-3 ziphakanyiswe ngokumelene nezimbangela eziwumsuka ezingu-6. Engezani esisodwa, bese nahlulela ukuthi isenzo ngasinye siyayithinta yini imbangela ngayinye.
Nibuka njengesivakashi. Faka igama lomsebenzisi ukuze nijoyine futhi nihlanganyele.
Ezinye izigomelo zinomthelela kwezinye ngesiyingi
↺ Every state judges the case by what it costs t → So the organisation that knows most says least
Isiyingi singaba yinto yangempela etholakele — umjikelezo ozondlayo — noma isixhumanisi esingakaze sinqunywe ngempela ukuthi siya kuphi. Ibalazwe lithatha isiyingi njengendawo eyodwa, ngakho akukho okungaphakathi kwaso okuyimpande ngokwako. Uma kungokwesibili, kufanele isibhangqa sibuyiselwe egumbini.Nikezani izimbangela eziwumsuka amaphuzu kuqala
kungani
Umkhuba wale ndlela uqobo, ngaphambi kokuthi kuphakanyiswe isenzo: imbangela ewumsuka ngayinye inikezwa amaphuzu angu-1–5 ngokuthi kuyenzeka kangakanani ukubhekana nayo, ukuthi ukubhekana nayo kungaba nomthelela ongakanani, nokuthi kungenzeka kangakanani ukuthi izixazulule yona ngaphandle kokungenelela. Okubalulekile kakhulu yizimpande ezinomthelela omkhulu, ezenzeka kalula futhi okungenzeki kalula ukuthi zizilungise — okubalulekile = umthelela + ukwenzeka − ukuzilungisa. Amaphuzu enziwa isilinganiso eqenjini lonke futhi aboniswa nokuthi bangaki abanikeze amaphuzu.
1 = phansi, 5 = phezulu. Amaphuzu enu; izilinganiso zeqembu eceleni kwawo.
| imbangela ewumsuka | kuyenzeka | umthelela | kuzilungisa kona | okubalulekile |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Every state judges the case by what it costs them | – | – | – | – |
| So the organisation that knows most says least | – | – | – | – |
| Naming it triggers obligations, so it is not named | – | – | – | – |
| Early warning systems produce reports nobody is obliged to answer | – | – | – | – |
| Acting early is politically costly and acting late is not punished | – | – | – | – |
| Speaking publicly ends the access that lets us feed people | – | – | – | – |
Ingabe isenzo ngasinye singayithinta imbangela ewumsuka ngayinye?
Phansi ohlangothini: izenzo abantu abaziphakamisile. Phezulu: izimbangela eziwumsuka ezitholwe yibalazwe. Isikwele ngasinye siyivoti elilodwa embuzweni owodwa — ingabe lesi senzo singayinciphisa kakhulu leyo mbangela? Uhlangothi olulodwa kumele lufinyelele ku-75% wamavoti afakiwe ukuze kunqunywe; uma kungenjalo isikwele sihlala sihlukene. Isikwele ngasinye sibonisa ukuthi amavoti aso ahlukene kanjani — yebo / kubi nakakhulu / cha — futhi isikwele sinqunywa uma okukodwa kwalokho kufinyelela ezingxenyeni ezintathu kwezine zawo.
kungani
Kuphendulwe ngo-75% wamavoti afakiwe, njengayo yonke eminye imibuzo elapha. Kuhlukene kusho ukuthi abantu bavotile futhi alukho uhlangothi olufinyelele kulelo zinga — kungumphumela, hhayi uhlu lokulinda, futhi kuhlala kuhlukene kuze kube abantu abanele bashintsha imibono yabo. Isikwele esingenqunywa muntu sihlala singanqunyiwe; asikaze sibalwe njengokuthi “cha”. Ukwahlulela isibhangqa ngasinye ngokwaso yikho okuvimbela isenzo esithandwayo ukuthi sinconywe ngokulungisa izinto esingazithinti.
| ISENZO | IZIMBANGELA EZIWUMSUKA · ingabe isenzo esingakwesobunxele siyakunciphisa? | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Every state judges the case by what it costs them | So the organisation that knows most says least | Naming it triggers obligations, so it is not named | Early warning systems produce reports nobody is obliged to answer | Acting early is politically costly and acting late is not punished | Speaking publicly ends the access that lets us feed people | |
| Protect the mandate of an organisation that speaks xoxa | ✗ cha, akukunciphisi 6 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 23 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 25 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 4 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 23 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 6 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 23 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 6 cha | akukanqunywa | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 24 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 5 cha |
| Fund prevention as a line, not as a response xoxa | ✗ cha, akukunciphisi 3 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 26 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 24 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 5 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 25 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 4 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 26 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 3 cha | akukanqunywa | ✗ cha, akukunciphisi 3 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 26 cha |
| A standing obligation to answer an early warning in writing, within days xoxa | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 24 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 5 cha | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 24 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 5 cha | ✗ cha, akukunciphisi 1 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 28 cha | ⚑ iqembu lihlukene 8 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 21 cha | akukanqunywa | ✓ yebo, kuyakunciphisa lokhu 23 yebo / 0 kubi nakakhulu / 6 cha |
Okunomthelela omkhulu kuze kube manje
Protect the mandate of an organisation that speaks sinciphisa 4 kwezimbangela eziwumsuka ezingu-6
Fund prevention as a line, not as a response sinciphisa 3 kwezimbangela eziwumsuka ezingu-6
A standing obligation to answer an early warning in writing, within days sinciphisa 3 kwezimbangela eziwumsuka ezingu-6
IZENZO EBALAZWENI
Kuboniswa: zonke izenzo igumbi elazahlulela. Kusebenza ngqo ku-5 kwezimbangela eziwumsuka ezingu-6. Akusebenzi ngqo ezimbangeleni eziwumsuka ezingu-1.
Kufundwe ezikweleni igumbi elazinquma esigabeni sezenzo, akukho okunye. Impande eluhlaza incishiswa okungenani yisenzo esisodwa kwezibonisiwe; empunga, akukho kuzo okusebenza kuyo ngqo; umugqa obomvu ojikelezayo usho ukuthi esinye sazo siyenza ibe imbi nakakhulu.
Yabelanani ngalokhu enikubonayo: njengesithombe · njengebalazwe elibukhoma kwenye iwebhusayithi
Inombolo ngayinye ebalazweni ikhomba imbangela ewumsuka leso senzo esiyinciphisayo.
① Protect the mandate of an organisation that speaks
② Fund prevention as a line, not as a response
③ A standing obligation to answer an early warning in writing, within days
KUSUKA EZENZWENI KUYA OHLELWENI
Ithebula lahlulela isenzo ngasinye ngokwaso. Uhlelo luyiqoqo lazo igumbi elingazenza ndawonye.
Amalungu akha izinhlelo ngezenzo ezinciphisa imbangela ewumsuka, bese igumbi liqhathanisa izinhlelo ezimbili ngesikhathi, ngezingxenye ezintathu kwezine zamavoti afakiwe, njengoba lahlulela konke okunye. Uhlelo ngalunye lubonisa ukuthi yiziphi izimbangela eziwumsuka olusebenza kuzo ngqo, yiziphi olungasebenzi kuzo, nokuthi yiziphi oluzenza zibe zimbi nakakhulu.
Umphathi angavula ukuqhathaniswa kwezinhlelo.
Lokho esilindele ukuthi kulandele
Izibikezelo ngezenzo: lokho okufanele isenzo ngasinye sikushintshe, indlela yokukukala, nokuthi kuhlolwe nini. Ngalolo suku, umuntu owayesegumbini ubhala okwenzeke ngempela eduze kwaso.
kungani
Ibalazwe lisho ukuthi yiziphi izenzo ezithinta yiziphi izimbangela. Alisho ukuthi ukhona yini owazenza, noma kukhona okwashintsha. Okubhalwe lapha kuyisibikezelo esinosuku nento yokukala, esabhalwa ngemva kokuzinza kwebalazwe. Uma usuku lufika, okwenzeke ngempela kubhalwa eduze kwaso futhi isibikezelo sihlala njengoba sasinjalo: esingalungile yisona esiwusizo. Akekho owavotela noma yikuphi kwalokhu futhi akushintshi lutho kulokho igumbi elakuthola.
kulindeleke 24 Mar 2027
isenzoProtect the mandate of an organisation that speaks
silindelemore warnings get a written answer once answering is somebody's duty
okukalwayo% of early warnings answered in writing within 14 days
ukuqagelaigumbi: 29 (isilinganiso esiphakathi sezingu-15, kusukela ku-15 kuya ku-60)
OKULANDELAYO
Lokho okutholwe yileli gumbi kuyisiqalo solunye uhlobo lwebalazwe. Umzuliswano ngamunye ongezansi uvuleka njengegumbi elisha elinabantu abafanayo, abasevele bamukelwe, kanye nalokho okudluliselwayo odongeni lwalo noma eceleni kwalo. Umzuliswano ushesha kunegumbi lokuqala: akekho ojoyinayo, umbuzo usuhleliwe, amakhadi adluliselwe asevele acacisiwe, futhi isigaba esingasenalutho lokwenziwa sivaleka ngokushesha. Umzuliswano ungalandelwa ngomunye.
Izenzo · izimbangela eziwumsuka yizo izenzo ezahlulelwa ngokumelene nazo; izenzo ezathinta eyodwa sezivele zisodongeni
Kufanele senzeni ngezimbangela eziwumsuka ezitholakele, futhi yini okufanele siqale ngayo?
Umphathi uvula umzuliswano olandelayo; isihlalo senu siyadlulela kuwo.