True Causes
DA
← oversigten
7/7 · Handlinger
30 personer · 34 idéer
gennemgang · tælles ikke
forhindringer · alle med linket · offentligt listet · i sammenslutning
tovholder: dens tovholder (forseglet)
30 personer · 34 idéer · 2 grupper · 3 rum i sammenslutning
Pas → · Logik → · protokol
↗ del dette kort
På et andet websted, som et levende kort:
Som billede: https://truecauses.org/d/d4b5d11/map.svg
Som data: alle vurderede par i dette rum (CSV). Hver påstand har sin egen adresse, /c/d4b5d11/<card>, listet under kortet.
Kreditering, når du offentliggør: Årsagskort: True Causes, https://truecauses.org/d/d4b5d11
SPØRGSMÅLET

Why does A&E make people wait for hours?

Foreslå, hvad der skal gøres, og vurder så, om hver handling ville flytte hver rod.

Forseglet for 42 dage siden: dette rum ved ikke længere, hvem der sad i det; kun dets tovholder er stadig navngivet. Det, det konkluderede, består.
30 ved bordet (heraf simulerede: 29) · 3 handlinger foreslået mod 4 grundårsager. Tilføj en, og vurder så, om hver handling flytter hver årsag.
Du ser med som gæst. Vælg et brugernavn for at komme med og deltage.
Nogle påstande påvirker hinanden i en cirkel
↺ Nobody tells you how long the wait will be → Being frightened makes everything take longer → Staff leave faster than we can hire them → I came here because I could not get seen anywh → …
En cirkel kan være et reelt fund — en kreds, der nærer sig selv — eller en forbindelse, hvis retning aldrig rigtig blev afgjort. Kortet behandler gruppen som ét punkt, så intet i den er en rod for sig selv. Hvis det er det sidste, er parret værd at give tilbage til rummet.
Giv grundårsagerne point først
hvorfor
Metodens egen praksis, før nogen handling foreslås: hver grundårsag får 1–5 point for, hvor gennemførligt det er at tage fat på den, hvor stor virkning det ville have, og hvor sandsynligt det er, at den løser sig selv uden indgriben. Prioritet går til grundårsager med stor virkning, høj gennemførlighed og lav sandsynlighed for at løse sig selv — prioritet = virkning + gennemførlighed − sandsynlighed. Pointene er gennemsnit for gruppen og vises med, hvor mange der gav point.
1 = lav, 5 = høj. Dine egne point; gruppens gennemsnit ved siden af.
grundårsaggennemførligvirkningløser sig selvprioritet
Beds are full because nobody can be discharged––––
Nobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away––––
The form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body––––
The GP said six weeks and it has been five months––––
Ville hver handling flytte hver grundårsag?
Ned langs siden: de handlinger, folk foreslog. Hen over toppen: de grundårsager, kortet fandt. Hvert felt er én stemme om ét spørgsmål — ville denne handling væsentligt mindske den årsag? Én side skal nå 75 % af de afgivne stemmer for at afgøre det; ellers forbliver feltet delt. Hvert felt viser, hvordan stemmerne faldt — ja / værre / nej — og et felt er afgjort, når ét af dem når tre fjerdedele af stemmerne.
hvorfor
Besvares ved 75 % af de afgivne stemmer, som alle andre spørgsmål her. Delt betyder, at folk stemte, og ingen side nåede den grænse — det er et resultat, ikke en kø, og det forbliver delt, indtil nok folk ændrer mening. Et felt, ingen afgør, forbliver uafgjort; det bliver aldrig til et nej. At vurdere hvert par for sig er det, der forhindrer, at en populær handling får æren for at løse ting, den ikke rører ved.
HANDLINGGRUNDÅRSAGER · mindsker handlingen til venstre det?
Beds are full because nobody can be dischargedNobody has ever asked me what would have kept me awayThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own bodyThe GP said six weeks and it has been five months
Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away diskutér✗ nej, det gør den ikke
4 ja / 0 værre / 25 nej
✓ ja, den mindsker dette
23 ja / 0 værre / 6 nej
⚑ gruppen delte sig
8 ja / 0 værre / 21 nej
ikke afgjort endnu
Tell people the expected wait, and update it diskutér✓ ja, den mindsker dette
28 ja / 0 værre / 1 nej
✓ ja, den mindsker dette
27 ja / 0 værre / 2 nej
✗ nej, det gør den ikke
6 ja / 0 værre / 23 nej
ikke afgjort endnu
Let one person who knows the patient stay with them diskutér✗ nej, det gør den ikke
4 ja / 0 værre / 25 nej
✗ nej, det gør den ikke
6 ja / 0 værre / 23 nej
✗ nej, det gør den ikke
4 ja / 0 værre / 25 nej
ikke afgjort endnu
Størst effekt indtil nu
Tell people the expected wait, and update it mindsker 2 af 4 grundårsager
Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away mindsker 1 af 4 grundårsager
HANDLINGERNE PÅ KORTET
Viser alle handlinger, rummet vurderede: den virker direkte på 2 af de 4 grundårsager. Den virker ikke direkte på 2.
Læst ud fra de felter, rummet afgjorde i fasen Handlinger, og intet andet. En grundårsag i grønt mindskes af mindst én af de viste handlinger; i gråt virker ingen af dem direkte på den; en rød kant betyder, at én af dem gør den værre.
I did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elsePeople wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees them → The same patients come back within a weekBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → People wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → The GP said six weeks and it has been five monthsBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → I was sent home at midnight with no way to get thereThe GP said six weeks and it has been five months → The interpreter was booked for twenty minutesNobody tells you how long the wait will be → Being frightened makes everything take longerNobody tells you how long the wait will be → I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedBeing frightened makes everything take longer → I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedThe interpreter was booked for twenty minutes → Nobody explained what the test was forStaff leave faster than we can hire them → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → Being frightened makes everything take longerI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI came here because I could not get seen anywhere else → Being frightened makes everything take longerI came here because I could not get seen anywhere else → My mother came home with no one to help her stand upNobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away → I have been in this corridor before and nothing changedI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → My mother came home with no one to help her stand upThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → People wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → You are moved three times and explain yourself three timesThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → Nobody explained what the test was forI was sent home at midnight with no way to get there → There is no water and no food after tenI was sent home at midnight with no way to get there → The same patients come back within a weekMy mother came home with no one to help her stand up → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beMy mother came home with no one to help her stand up → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not come sooner because I could not afford the tripI did not come soonerbecause I could not affordthe tripBeds are full because nobody can be discharged ② Tell people the expected wait, and update itBeds are full becausenobody can be discharged②hvad de viste handlinger gør ved denne grundårsagMINDSKET AF 1 HANDLINGNobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away ① Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away ② Tell people the expected wait, and update itNobody has ever asked mewhat would have kept meaway①②hvad de viste handlinger gør ved denne grundårsagMINDSKET AF 2 HANDLINGERThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own bodyThe form asks questions Icannot answer about my ownbodyhvad de viste handlinger gør ved denne grundårsagINGEN HANDLING VIRKERDIREKTE PÅ DENYou are moved three times and explain yourself three timesYou are moved three timesand explain yourself threetimesI have been in this corridor before and nothing changedI have been in thiscorridor before and nothingchangedPeople wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themPeople wait hours in acorridor before anyone seesthemI was sent home at midnight with no way to get thereI was sent home at midnightwith no way to get thereThe GP said six weeks and it has been five monthsThe GP said six weeks andit has been five monthshvad de viste handlinger gør ved denne grundårsagINGEN HANDLING VIRKERDIREKTE PÅ DENThe same patients come back within a weekThe same patients come backwithin a weekThere is no water and no food after tenThere is no water and nofood after tenThe interpreter was booked for twenty minutesThe interpreter was bookedfor twenty minutesBeing frightened makes everything take longerBeing frightened makeseverything take longerdel af en feedbackløkke⟳I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI came here because I couldnot get seen anywhere elsedel af en feedbackløkke⟳Nobody tells you how long the wait will beNobody tells you how longthe wait will bedel af en feedbackløkke⟳I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedI did not know a pharmacycould have helpeddel af en feedbackløkke⟳Staff leave faster than we can hire themStaff leave faster than wecan hire themdel af en feedbackløkke⟳My mother came home with no one to help her stand upMy mother came home with noone to help her stand updel af en feedbackløkke⟳Nobody explained what the test was forNobody explained what thetest was for
Hvert tal på kortet markerer en grundårsag, som den handling mindsker.
① Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away
② Tell people the expected wait, and update it
③ Let one person who knows the patient stay with them
FRA HANDLINGER TIL EN PLAN
Skemaet vurderede hver handling for sig. En plan er et sæt af dem, som rummet ville gennemføre sammen.
Medlemmerne sætter planer sammen af de handlinger, der mindsker en grundårsag, og rummet sammenligner planerne to ad gangen, ved tre fjerdedele af de afgivne stemmer, sådan som det har vurderet alt andet. Hver plan viser, hvilke grundårsager den virker direkte på, hvilke ikke, og hvilke den gør værre.
Tovholderen kan åbne en plansammenligning.
Hvad vi forventer, der følger
Forudsigelser om handlingerne: hvad hver af dem skal ændre, hvordan det måles, og hvornår der skal tjekkes. På datoen skriver en, der var i rummet, hvad der faktisk skete, ved siden af.
hvorfor
Et kort siger, hvilke handlinger der flytter hvilke årsager. Det siger ikke, om nogen gjorde dem, eller om noget ændrede sig. En post her er en forudsigelse med en dato og noget at måle, skrevet efter at kortet var afgjort. Når datoen kommer, skrives det, der faktisk skete, ved siden af, og forudsigelsen står, som den var: en forkert er den nyttige slags. Ingen har stemt om noget af dette, og det ændrer intet af det, rummet fandt.
frist 23. januar 2027
handlingTell people the expected wait, and update it
vi forventerpeople know what they are waiting for and how long
målt ved% of patients told an expected wait within 30 minutes of arrival
gætrummet: 48 (median af 15, spredning 20 til 85)
HVAD NU
Det, dette rum fandt, er startinput til en anden slags kort. Hver runde nedenfor åbner som et nyt rum med de samme mennesker, allerede lukket ind, og med det, der følger med, på sin væg eller ved siden af den. En runde er hurtigere end et første rum: ingen kommer ind, spørgsmålet er formuleret, medbragte sedler er allerede præciseret, og en fase, hvor der ikke er mere at gøre, lukker med det samme. En runde kan følges af en ny.
Handlinger · grundårsagerne er det, handlingerne vurderes op imod; handlinger, der flyttede en af dem, er allerede på væggen
Hvad skal vi gøre ved de fundne grundårsager, og hvad først?
Tovholderen åbner næste runde; din plads følger med.