True Causes
SR
← početna
7/7 · Akcije
30 osoba · 34 ideje
probni prolaz · ne računa se
prepreke · svako sa linkom · na javnom spisku · federacija uključena
vodi: njen voditelj (zapečaćeno)
30 osoba · 34 ideje · 2 grupe · 3 sobe u federaciji
Pasoš → · Logika → · zapis
↗ podeli ovu mapu
Na drugom sajtu, kao živa mapa:
Kao slika: https://truecauses.org/d/d4b5d11/map.svg
Kao podaci: svi ocenjeni parovi u ovoj sobi (CSV). Svaka tvrdnja ima svoju adresu, /c/d4b5d11/<card>, navedenu ispod mape.
Navedite izvor kada objavljujete: Uzročna mapa: True Causes, https://truecauses.org/d/d4b5d11
PITANJE

Why does A&E make people wait for hours?

Predložite šta da se uradi, pa procenite da li bi svaka akcija pomerila svaki koren.

Zapečaćeno pre 42 dana: ova soba više ne zna ko je sedeo u njoj; po imenu ostaje samo njen voditelj. Ono do čega je došla ostaje.
za stolom: 30 (simulirano: 29) · 3 predložene akcije za osnovne uzroke (4). Dodajte jednu, pa procenite da li svaka akcija pomera svaki uzrok.
Gledate kao gost. Unesite korisničko ime da biste se pridružili i učestvovali.
Neke tvrdnje utiču jedna na drugu u krug
↺ Nobody tells you how long the wait will be → Being frightened makes everything take longer → Staff leave faster than we can hire them → I came here because I could not get seen anywh → …
Krug može biti pravi nalaz — ciklus koji sam sebe hrani — ili veza čiji smer nikad nije zaista rešen. Mapa takav skup tretira kao jedan čvor, pa ništa unutar njega nije osnovni uzrok samo za sebe. Ako je posredi ovo drugo, vredi vratiti par sobi.
Najpre ocenite osnovne uzroke
zašto
Praksa same metode, pre nego što se predloži ijedna akcija: svaki osnovni uzrok dobija ocenu od 1 do 5 za to koliko je izvodljivo baviti se njime, koliki bi uticaj to imalo i koliko je verovatno da će se rešiti sam od sebe, bez ikakve intervencije. Prednost imaju osnovni uzroci sa velikim uticajem, visokom izvodljivošću i malom verovatnoćom da se reše sami — prioritet = uticaj + izvodljivost − verovatnoća. Ocene se uprosečuju za celu grupu i prikazuju uz broj onih koji su ocenjivali.
1 = nisko, 5 = visoko. Vaše ocene; pored njih proseci grupe.
osnovni uzrokizvodljivouticajrešava se samoprioritet
Beds are full because nobody can be discharged––––
Nobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away––––
The form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body––––
The GP said six weeks and it has been five months––––
Koja akcija bi pomerila koji osnovni uzrok?
Sa strane: akcije koje su ljudi predložili. Gore: osnovni uzroci koje je mapa pronašla. Svako polje je jedno glasanje o jednom pitanju — da li bi ova akcija značajno smanjila taj uzrok? Jedna strana mora da dostigne 75% datih glasova da bi se pitanje rešilo; inače polje ostaje podeljeno. Svako polje pokazuje kako su pali glasovi — da / gore / ne — a polje je rešeno kada jedno od toga dobije tri četvrtine glasova.
zašto
Odgovor važi na 75% datih glasova, kao i svako drugo pitanje ovde. Podeljeno znači da su ljudi glasali, a nijedna strana nije dostigla taj prag — to je rezultat, a ne red čekanja, i ostaje podeljeno dok se dovoljno ljudi ne predomisli. Polje koje niko ne reši ostaje neodlučeno; nikad ne postaje „ne”. Ocenjivanje svakog para posebno sprečava da se popularnoj akciji pripiše da rešava stvari koje ne dotiče.
AKCIJAOSNOVNI UZROCI · da li ga akcija u levoj koloni umanjuje?
Beds are full because nobody can be dischargedNobody has ever asked me what would have kept me awayThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own bodyThe GP said six weeks and it has been five months
Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away diskutuj✗ ne, ne smanjuje
4 da / 0 gore / 25 ne
✓ da, smanjuje ovo
23 da / 0 gore / 6 ne
⚑ grupa se podelila
8 da / 0 gore / 21 ne
još nije odlučeno
Tell people the expected wait, and update it diskutuj✓ da, smanjuje ovo
28 da / 0 gore / 1 ne
✓ da, smanjuje ovo
27 da / 0 gore / 2 ne
✗ ne, ne smanjuje
6 da / 0 gore / 23 ne
još nije odlučeno
Let one person who knows the patient stay with them diskutuj✗ ne, ne smanjuje
4 da / 0 gore / 25 ne
✗ ne, ne smanjuje
6 da / 0 gore / 23 ne
✗ ne, ne smanjuje
4 da / 0 gore / 25 ne
još nije odlučeno
Najveći učinak zasad
Tell people the expected wait, and update it smanjuje 2 od 4 osnovna uzroka
Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away smanjuje 1 od 4 osnovna uzroka
AKCIJE NA MAPI
Prikazano: sve akcije koje je soba ocenila. Direktno deluje na 2 od 4 osnovna uzroka. Bez direktne akcije: 2.
Pročitano samo iz polja koja je soba rešila u fazi Akcije. Osnovni uzrok u zelenom smanjuje bar jedna od prikazanih akcija; u sivom nijedna od njih ne deluje direktno na njega; crveni obrub znači da ga jedna od njih pogoršava.
Podelite ovaj prikaz: kao sliku · kao živu mapu za drugi sajt
I did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not come sooner because I could not afford the trip → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elsePeople wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees them → The same patients come back within a weekBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → People wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → The GP said six weeks and it has been five monthsBeds are full because nobody can be discharged → I was sent home at midnight with no way to get thereThe GP said six weeks and it has been five months → The interpreter was booked for twenty minutesNobody tells you how long the wait will be → Being frightened makes everything take longerNobody tells you how long the wait will be → I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedBeing frightened makes everything take longer → I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedThe interpreter was booked for twenty minutes → Nobody explained what the test was forStaff leave faster than we can hire them → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → Being frightened makes everything take longerI have been in this corridor before and nothing changed → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI came here because I could not get seen anywhere else → Being frightened makes everything take longerI came here because I could not get seen anywhere else → My mother came home with no one to help her stand upNobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away → I have been in this corridor before and nothing changedI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI did not know a pharmacy could have helped → My mother came home with no one to help her stand upThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → People wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → You are moved three times and explain yourself three timesThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own body → Nobody explained what the test was forI was sent home at midnight with no way to get there → There is no water and no food after tenI was sent home at midnight with no way to get there → The same patients come back within a weekMy mother came home with no one to help her stand up → Nobody tells you how long the wait will beMy mother came home with no one to help her stand up → Staff leave faster than we can hire themI did not come sooner because I could not afford the tripI did not come soonerbecause I could not affordthe tripBeds are full because nobody can be discharged ② Tell people the expected wait, and update itBeds are full becausenobody can be discharged②šta prikazane akcije čine ovom osnovnom uzroku1 AKCIJA GA SMANJUJENobody has ever asked me what would have kept me away ① Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away ② Tell people the expected wait, and update itNobody has ever asked mewhat would have kept meaway①②šta prikazane akcije čine ovom osnovnom uzroku2 AKCIJE GA SMANJUJUThe form asks questions I cannot answer about my own bodyThe form asks questions Icannot answer about my ownbodyšta prikazane akcije čine ovom osnovnom uzrokuNIJEDNA AKCIJA NE DELUJEDIREKTNO NA NJEGAYou are moved three times and explain yourself three timesYou are moved three timesand explain yourself threetimesI have been in this corridor before and nothing changedI have been in thiscorridor before and nothingchangedPeople wait hours in a corridor before anyone sees themPeople wait hours in acorridor before anyone seesthemI was sent home at midnight with no way to get thereI was sent home at midnightwith no way to get thereThe GP said six weeks and it has been five monthsThe GP said six weeks andit has been five monthsšta prikazane akcije čine ovom osnovnom uzrokuNIJEDNA AKCIJA NE DELUJEDIREKTNO NA NJEGAThe same patients come back within a weekThe same patients come backwithin a weekThere is no water and no food after tenThere is no water and nofood after tenThe interpreter was booked for twenty minutesThe interpreter was bookedfor twenty minutesBeing frightened makes everything take longerBeing frightened makeseverything take longerdeo povratne petlje⟳I came here because I could not get seen anywhere elseI came here because I couldnot get seen anywhere elsedeo povratne petlje⟳Nobody tells you how long the wait will beNobody tells you how longthe wait will bedeo povratne petlje⟳I did not know a pharmacy could have helpedI did not know a pharmacycould have helpeddeo povratne petlje⟳Staff leave faster than we can hire themStaff leave faster than wecan hire themdeo povratne petlje⟳My mother came home with no one to help her stand upMy mother came home with noone to help her stand updeo povratne petlje⟳Nobody explained what the test was forNobody explained what thetest was for
Svaki broj na mapi označava osnovni uzrok koji ta akcija smanjuje.
① Ask every returning patient what would have kept them away
② Tell people the expected wait, and update it
③ Let one person who knows the patient stay with them
OD AKCIJA DO PLANA
Tabela je ocenila svaku akciju zasebno. Plan je skup akcija koje bi soba sprovela zajedno.
Članovi sastavljaju planove od akcija koje smanjuju neki osnovni uzrok, a soba poredi planove po dva, sa tri četvrtine datih glasova, kao što je ocenila i sve ostalo. Svaki plan pokazuje na koje osnovne uzroke direktno deluje, na koje ne i koje pogoršava.
Voditelj može da otvori poređenje planova.
Šta očekujemo da usledi
Predviđanja o akcijama: šta bi svaka trebalo da promeni, kako to izmeriti i kada proveriti. Tog datuma neko ko je bio u sobi upisuje pored predviđanja šta se zaista dogodilo.
zašto
Mapa kaže koje akcije pomeraju koje uzroke. Ne kaže da li ih je iko sproveo, niti da li se išta promenilo. Unos ovde je predviđanje sa datumom i nečim što se meri, napisano pošto je mapa rešena. Kada dođe taj datum, pored njega se upiše šta se zaista dogodilo, a predviđanje ostaje kakvo je bilo: pogrešno je upravo ono korisno. Niko nije glasao ni o čemu od ovoga i to ne menja ništa od onoga što je soba utvrdila.
rok: 23. januar 2027.
akcijaTell people the expected wait, and update it
očekujemopeople know what they are waiting for and how long
merilo% of patients told an expected wait within 30 minutes of arrival
procenesoba: 48 (medijana; procena: 15; raspon od 20 do 85)
ŠTA DALJE
Ono što je ova soba našla polazni je ulaz druge vrste mape. Svaka runda ispod otvara se kao nova soba sa istim ljudima, već primljenim, i sa onim što se prenosi na njenom zidu ili pored njega. Runda je brža od prve sobe: niko se ne pridružuje, pitanje je sročeno, prenete kartice su već pojašnjene, a faza u kojoj nema šta da se radi zatvara se odmah. Za jednom rundom može da usledi druga.
Akcije · osnovni uzroci su ono prema čemu se akcije procenjuju; akcije koje su pomerile neki od njih već su na zidu
Šta treba da uradimo povodom nađenih osnovnih uzroka, i šta prvo?
Voditelj otvara sledeću rundu; vaše mesto se prenosi.