READ FROM PUBLIC DISCUSSION
The pool
Claims a model read out of public threads, each with a link to the comment it came from. Nobody judged any of it: a room certifies a link when three quarters of a group say so, and nothing here has been through that. A claim came from one comment; a link came from one comment; no path through this was asserted by anybody. What is counted is how many communities and how many distinct people — never a total, which would read as a score it has not earned. Open questions.
395 claims · 5 asserted links · 48 the atlas already holds5 thin
ASSERTED LINKS
Building more housing in desirable areas attracts more people. → Upzoning would not make a place like Manhattan more affordable.
thin · refused in news.ycombinator.com
Local control laws allow anyone to stop development in others' yards. → Zoning irresponsibly near heavy transit restricts housing development.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Laws and regulation prevent housing supply from increasing → Most voters are homeowners with a vested interest in increasing home value
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Increasing the supply of housing will lower the price in the long term → Increasing the supply of housing will raise the price in the short term
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Tokyo solves affordability with economies of scale around prefabricated buildings. → The US needs to relax zoning rules for economies of scale.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
CLAIMS
Cash buyers are unaffected by mortgage rates and buy properties.
A city's land is a scarce resource that cannot be freely allocated.
Tourism intensification deteriorates local residents' ability to afford housing.
Decades of car-centric city planning caused the lack of public transport.
Expensive licensing of tradesmen increases construction costs.
Network effects keep people on the West Coast instead of moving.
Building restrictions increase house prices by limiting supply
Upzoning can make the cost of land per unit affordable.
The city council refuses to say no to the luxury condo makers
California's lack of by right zoning creates uncertainty for developers.
Rising supply in cities forces sellers to offer concessions.
More units increase property taxes for municipal services.
There is not enough planning permission.
Building denser housing reduces costs per unit for residents.
Supply is artificially constrained in most jurisdictions.
Copenhagen restricts non-resident ownership to improve housing affordability.
Tysons developed in response to the stricter zoning in DC.
Speculation raises house prices due to future expectations
Rapid house price inflation has squeezed social renting and home ownership.
Private equity firms are buying homes and renting them out.
Mortgages have been hard to obtain
Bad zoning creates a manufactured crisis in housing affordability.
The relatively high interest rate makes financing hard.
Developers choose to build higher-priced options to maximize profits.
Building high-end housing damages the poor and middle-class.
Reducing parking requirements can help develop a core area.
Housing has been underbuilt for decades in economically vital areas.
Using housing for retirement savings is not sustainable.
The housing crisis is caused by restrictions on where housing can be built.
Noise deters others from living in dense housing areas.
House builders earn zero profit on affordable homes, making them unattractive.
Mortgage rates are rising, hurting homebuyer demand and affordability.
Natural clustering tendencies of economic activities create dead zones.
There is practically zero inventory of condos available.
Stamp duty discourages people from moving.
Not all locations are equally good places for cities.
Restrictive zoning laws create housing unaffordability in cities.
NIMBYs and lack of investment broke traditional paths to adulthood.
Waterloo Region needs to adjust zoning to allow more housing.
Natural clustering tendencies of economic activities lead to housing issues.
Cities zoning irresponsibly near heavy transit causes housing unaffordability.
Treating housing as an investment causes cities to be broken.
NYC is more affordable than the Bay Area due to upzoning.
City politicians can't fight the NIMBY argument against density.
Compact development curbs land development and challenges affordability.
The retraction of government support for affordable housing increases costs.
High-demand areas drive up house prices in London.
Spain's Airbnb regulations make it harder to buy flats for short-term lets.
Rejecting structural changes exacerbates the housing crisis for most people.
Seattle is the fastest growing city in the US, thus demand is increasing constantly.
Zoning is the issue for housing affordability.
Policies that limit growth are discriminatory and should be removed.
NIMBYs winning leads to worsening housing shortages
People build elsewhere when distance costs less than regulatory cleanup.
Increased demand around RTP may pressure housing prices if affordability is not prioritized.
Less restrictive zoning makes more building projects financially feasible.
The US needs to relax zoning rules for economies of scale.
Local government policies drive the housing crisis.
Zoning keeps builders from making new housing in NYC.
Housing needed for workers in the city doesn't exist.