READ FROM PUBLIC DISCUSSION
The pool
Claims a model read out of public threads, each with a link to the comment it came from. Nobody judged any of it: a room certifies a link when three quarters of a group say so, and nothing here has been through that. A claim came from one comment; a link came from one comment; no path through this was asserted by anybody. What is counted is how many communities and how many distinct people — never a total, which would read as a score it has not earned. Open questions.
395 claims · 5 asserted links · 48 the atlas already holds5 thin
ASSERTED LINKS
Building more housing in desirable areas attracts more people. → Upzoning would not make a place like Manhattan more affordable.
thin · refused in news.ycombinator.com
Local control laws allow anyone to stop development in others' yards. → Zoning irresponsibly near heavy transit restricts housing development.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Laws and regulation prevent housing supply from increasing → Most voters are homeowners with a vested interest in increasing home value
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Increasing the supply of housing will lower the price in the long term → Increasing the supply of housing will raise the price in the short term
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
Tokyo solves affordability with economies of scale around prefabricated buildings. → The US needs to relax zoning rules for economies of scale.
thin · asserted in news.ycombinator.com
CLAIMS
We have a housing crisis because this country has not built enough homes that people can afford.
New condo buildings do not help affordable housing.
Rent control created a disincentive to build new rentals
Local governments in CA are convoluted and corrupt.
Cost inflation and staff shortages challenge the building sector.
Contractors turn down jobs because they are at capacity in their neighborhood.
Illicit finance flows into property markets, driving up prices and reducing affordability.
The problem is lack of housing in desirable locations.
People are forced to cluster in large cities due to traditional working practices.
Big corporations and investors have driven up home prices.
Government owned land is rarely sold due to protected status.
Reducing average square footage would help in expensive land areas.
Vulnerable families live far from employment centers due to housing costs.
San Francisco has a complicated review process for permit approval.
AirBnB inflates housing prices, so regulation is good for locals
Many ordinances require buildings to have parking spots.
Developers tear down good homes to build multiple apartments.
Middle and upper income people want mixed use developments, driving prices up.
Mixed-use areas allow density to work out pretty well.
High numbers of second homes and holiday lets reduce available housing.
Housing is unaffordable due to an artificially created shortage.
Living in the urban core saves money on transportation costs.
Weird regulations and anti-housing activists distort housing comparisons.
Zoning prevents building homes where people need them.
The UK planning system requires state permission for every building.
Directly restricting price won't make room for all the people who want to live here.
Canada has a significant shortage of skilled trades.
California refugees drive up housing prices in Oregon.
Everything will increase in value because of less supply than demand.
America adds between 600k-1.2M immigrants per year, adding strain to supply
Housing prices increase above inflation due to a long-term macro bubble.
Economic disparity has gotten so bad that affordability no longer aligns.
Most cities don't have great public transit alternatives.
Suburban and rural homes take tax dollars from city centers.
Internet companies could hire remotely to avoid over-populated hubs.